Welcome to Polly Ann Ice Cream
At Polly Ann Ice Cream, we celebrate a legacy that dates back to the heart of San Francisco. Nestled on Noriega Street, this beloved shop offers a delightful twist on traditional gelato, featuring an astounding array of over 50 unique flavors, including beloved Asian-inspired selections like Taro, Black Sesame, and Jasmine Tea. Our house specialties, such as the indulgent jumbo milkshake and gourmet sundaes, combine rich, creamy textures with a symphony of flavors, ensuring each delightful scoop transports you back to childhood bliss. With friendly service and a cozy ambiance, every visit promises not just ice cream, but a nostalgic experience worth savoring.
-
3138 Noriega St, San Francisco, CA 94122 Hotline: (415) 664-2472
Welcome to the whimsical world of Polly Ann Ice Cream, a beloved gem nestled on Noriega Street in the vibrant city of San Francisco. With a rich history that has delighted taste buds since its inception, Polly Ann has become a staple for both locals and visitors alike, drawing ice cream enthusiasts with its inviting ambiance and a dazzling array of over 50 unique flavors.
Upon entering Polly Ann, you’re greeted by a clean and charming interior that feels both nostalgic and refreshing. The staff, known for their friendless and enthusiasm, are always ready to guide you through your ice cream journey. They generously offer samples, ensuring you find the perfect scoop to satisfy your cravings.
- House Specialty: One of the standout offerings is the Ice Cream Quart at $18, perfect for indulgent late-night cravings or family gatherings.
- For a lighter treat, consider a Junior Cup for only $4.50, allowing you to mix and match exotic flavors like Mango and Lychee, both popular among returning customers.
- Don’t miss out on their creatively crafted Sundaes, served with hot fudge, caramel, and delightful toppings for just $11.50.
- For those looking to share (or indulge solo), their Regular Milkshake packs a punch at 24 oz for $12, available in a plethora of flavors.
Speaking of flavors, the selections at Polly Ann are nothing short of remarkable. You’ll find traditional staples alongside adventurous options that will tickle your taste buds. Standout flavors include Taro, Jasmine Tea, and Black Sesame, often lauded by customers for their authenticity and rich, creamy textures. The Bumpy Freeway, reminiscent of classic rocky road, mixes chocolate ice cream with satisfying chunks of nuts and marshmallows, earning rave reviews for its decadent taste.
Regulars like Karen C. celebrate Polly Ann’s ability to evoke nostalgia with every scoop, while newcomers like Deangela S. are pleasantly surprised by the variety and quality. Many also appreciate the option to split scoops for just 50 cents, allowing adventurous eaters the freedom to explore more flavors without commitment.
In addition to ice cream, Polly Ann offers delightful treats such as Jumbo Cookies and even Affogatos, creating a versatile menu that satisfies all dessert cravings. With its combination of quality ingredients and innovative flavors, Polly Ann Ice Cream not only stands out as an ice cream shop but also as a community hub where sweet memories are made.
Whether you’re a longtime fan or a curious first-time visitor, Polly Ann Ice Cream invites you to dive into a delicious experience that celebrates both tradition and the daring spirit of flavor. Don't miss your chance to savor a scoop (or two) of happiness and discover why this local treasure remains an integral part of San Francisco’s dessert landscape.
Got a junior cup with mango and lychee. Good size -2 big scopes for $4.50. Not a bad deal. Mango wasn't the usual mango. A bit tangy. Lychee was good with bits of lychee. I wanted sesame at first but they didn't have it in their 50+ flavors. Tried the pineapple hibiscus, it was interesting. But not enough to have a scoop.
Was blown away by their unique flavors! Their specialty Asian-inspired options like Black Sesame and Jasmine Tea were popular. They have vegan too! Friendly staff let you sample before deciding. generous portions and reasonable prices.
ice cream is pretty good! The last few times I went, they were pretty enthusiastic. This time around, they were pretty tired. Ambiance: cute, clean, it's pretty nice.
Great ice cream spot! Has an old school feel on the inside and the prices are reasonable. The staff were friendly. We ordered a chocolate brownie shake, a scoop of the boba ice cream, and the chocolate chunk cookie. It was all delicious and will definetly be coming back.
Can't believe that I haven't written a review for Polly Ann yet but I guess that makes sense since I've been going to Polly Ann since before Yelp was even a thought! Tl;dr: Polly Ann has the OG Asian-inspired ice creams and continues to churn out (see what I did there?) both classic and new original flavors that are high quality, creamy, and on point. Taro will forever and always be my go to, but jasmine tea is a really close second favorite! I've been going to Polly Ann since I was a wee child, back when they were in their old location halfway up the block. They may not have the cool steps up to the highest counter ever anymore, but the ice cream is the same. It's rare for things that I loved as a child to withstand the test of time and maturity of my taste buds, but Polly Ann has been able to consistently provide the nostalgia associated with going out for ice cream and the positive experience of calories well spent. They've kept the cool tiles for their menu and the roulette wheel if you can't decide, but the new space is bright and open, and the freezers are easy access to pick up a quick pint/quart/gallon on your way home. The flavors: As above, taro is my favorite and I can't leave without one scoop of at least that. Jasmine tea, turkish coffee, green tea, lychee, coffee & oreo cookie, and black sesame are all excellent. If you love creamy ice cream with flavors exactly as you would imagine and hope for them to taste, you can't go wrong with Polly Ann. Polly Ann is totally underrated. I continue to be surprised that it doesn't have lines out the door every time I go. But, guess that means more ice cream for me!
Long overdue review! I used to go to middle school right down the street so Polly Ann's was an afterschool staple :) I'm so glad to see them still open & thriving! I love all of the different flavors they have here, it's so hard to pick just one! They allow you to get a split scoop for an extra 50 cents. We ended up getting a congee / coffee brownie split scoop. I love how the congee tasted like a creamy rice pudding. It was really refreshing! The brownie bits in the coffee ice cream were generous and the actual coffee ice cream itself was the perfect sweetness. The staff here are all so kind, friendly, and patient. They really take their time answering any questions and giving out any samples that you want to try. The highlight of my visit was the free pup cone they gave us! It's a small scoop of vanilla ice cream on a tiny waffle cone. My dog absolutely loved it!
Pretty average ice cream shop. The workers are super friendly and there are a lot of flavors, but it's definitely an "out of convenience" shop rather than a destination ice cream shop. The prices were average for ice cream in the bay too. The coffee with brownies was the best flavor and had a good amount of brownie chunks
I have passed by this ice cream shop and decided to come for a sweet treat after a late lunch. I'm so glad I did! The interior is very cute inside. There are a couple tables to sit. There are plenty of workers to assist you so the wait is not that long. They have so many flavors. I was surprised to see they had some Asian flavors, but also, don't be shy to ask what some of them are because the staff is very friendly and was patient to let me try a couple. The Star Wars flavor is what I ended up getting, it was a birthday cake flavored ice cream with marshmallows and sprinkles. I also got a black sesame that had great smoky flavor. If you split a junior (two flavors), then it is just an additional 50 cents, if you're not feeling like too much ice cream, but want a taste. They have a lot more on the menu with brownies, cookies and a possibility for an affogato. I think I even saw a sign for sandwiches? Looking forward to coming here again to try out more flavors. Consider this place for your next ice cream craving.
My first time coming here and would definitely come back! They have so many flavors to choose from and you can sample the ice cream to help you choose what to get. The staff was patient with me as I was choosing which flavor to get. I ended up ordering their Bumpy Freeway and Matcha Green Tea ice cream. The bumpy freeway is similar to rocky road ice cream, it's very chocolatey and includes nuts & marshmallows. Their matcha green tea ice cream had the perfect sweetness and matcha flavor, i throughly enjoyed it! I also tried their fruity flavors including Honeydew and Lychee. Both flavors were tasty, but I did like the honeydew better since the honeydew flavor was strong. I recommend trying this ice cream place if you're in the area.